• Welcome
  • About Me
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • In The Media
  • Contact
Menu

Jamie Katuna

Embracing Creativity in Medicine. Join Me.

Your Custom Text Here

Jamie Katuna

  • Welcome
  • About Me
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • In The Media
  • Contact

Why Giving Up Control Is The Best Thing You Can Do

December 30, 2017 Jamie Katuna
FullSizeRender-4.jpg

 

A common error is made when training a horse. It goes like this: 

A rider’s horse is in the field, hundreds of feet away. The rider calls to the horse—nothing. The rider whistles—still nothing. Eventually the rider marches through the grass, up to the disobedient horse, and yanks on its halter angrily: “You should’ve came when I called!” 

The next time the rider comes to the field and calls for the horse, the horse stays as far away as possible. It won’t want anything to do with that person, because all it remembers is being marched up to and yelled at. 

Essentially, the rider felt insecure without control. Things were not occurring the way he wanted them to go in his head, so in a fit of frustration the rider sabotages his purpose. It takes a long time to undo the damage of this initial error. 

Doesn’t this sound familiar? We make spur-of-the-moment decisions after our insecurities have led us to anger, frustration, or jealousy. We sabotage the things we say we want because we’re blinded by needing control. We take things personally: Instead of looking at people (or horses) as flawed beings who will do what they want to do, we think they do things to us or in spite of us. In reacting to those very moments, we sabotage ourselves. 

The experienced trainer handles the situation differently. The experienced trainer calls the horse, and again, the horse doesn’t come. So she marches through the grass to the horse, but instead of handing out punishment, she hands out praise. She gives the horse treats and scratches its ears. 

The next time the trainer appears in the field, the horse is more engaged and willing to interact with this person. Ultimately, it is much more willing to be trained. 

By relinquishing that initial desire to establish control and dominance, the trainer gets what she wants. She didn’t have to “get back” at the horse. She took nothing personally, she understood the process and approached it with love.

Now. How does this apply to medicine? 

In medicine, we want control. We want to tell someone what they should do, and we want them to go home and do it. There is common complaint from medical professionals that they’re not able to help their patients because their patients don’t want to change. The cheetos-and-alcohol filled diets, the sedentary lifestyle, and the unaddressed stress are assumed to be constant variables of which physicians have no discernible influence. 

This leads to frustration and anger: why would you help someone who doesn’t want to be helped? And my answer to that would be: you wouldn’t. But, patients do want to be helped, we just interact the wrong way. 

Nobody is receptive to being controlled. Patients feel patronized. Clinicians feel powerless. It is always a lose-lose situation when one person tries to control another. (This applies to the physician-patient relationship, to significant others, to children, to anybody.) Control is never the answer. 

The answer is two-fold: First, compassion. Second, detachment. Let me explain. 

First, compassion. This consists of genuine concern for someone and a desire to help them. This is not sympathy, which says “I feel bad for you;” and it is not empathy, which says “I feel what you feel.” Compassion says “I recognize what you’re going through and I want to help you.” It is an authentic caring for another human without going there yourself (because if you are suffering, you cannot give them your best). 

A compassionate relationship is based in patience, in understanding, and in love for another human. If a patient does not do what the clinician recommends, the clinician has the same options the trainer approaching the horse in the pasture has. Either get upset and retaliate for the undesired behavior, or approach the situation lovingly and curiously. The former option is easier, but the latter option has profoundly more impactful results. 

The second aspect of a healthy relationship (again, this may be physician-patient, significant others, parents, or friends) is more counterintuitive: detachment. This means we should not be personally invested in the actions of another human. I can be excited for someone, or sorry for him, or happy, or angry—but I should always keep in mind that he is autonomous and has chosen his behavior in a way that has nothing to do with me personally. The personal detachment prevents defensive reactions. 

For example, if a patient does not do what a clinician recommends, it can manifest in several ways. A personally attached clinician might become frustrated, saying, “why didn’t you do what I told you to do?” And unattached clinician would ask, “why doesn’t this seem to be working for you?” It is a minor change but has very different results in dealing with another person. Patients want someone who will work with them rather than order them around. And if we want patients to do what we recommend, we must—counterintuitively—relinquish our desire for control.

The next time something isn’t going the way you imagined it to go, be reminded of which type of horse trainer you want to be. Will you become angry and desperate for control? Or will you become curious and approach the situation with love? 

I hope we are all able to choose the latter option in this new year.

 

MORE BLOG POSTS
Nov 26, 2018
Why Changing Behavior Can Be So Hard
Nov 26, 2018
Nov 26, 2018
Nov 24, 2018
An Open Letter to Dr. Apovian, Who Wants to Prescribe Pills for Obesity
Nov 24, 2018
Nov 24, 2018
Aug 28, 2018
The Way Learning Should Be
Aug 28, 2018
Aug 28, 2018
The Desperation For Vigilance Around Health Information
Jul 3, 2018
The Desperation For Vigilance Around Health Information
Jul 3, 2018
Jul 3, 2018
My Friend Got Fired: What Happens When Physicians Embrace Advocacy
Jun 10, 2018
My Friend Got Fired: What Happens When Physicians Embrace Advocacy
Jun 10, 2018
Jun 10, 2018
Advice For Incoming Medical Students
May 24, 2018
Advice For Incoming Medical Students
May 24, 2018
May 24, 2018
You Don't Have To Decide On A Specialty Right Now
Apr 30, 2018
You Don't Have To Decide On A Specialty Right Now
Apr 30, 2018
Apr 30, 2018
You Approached It Like It Was Heavy, So It Was
Apr 1, 2018
You Approached It Like It Was Heavy, So It Was
Apr 1, 2018
Apr 1, 2018
Unlearn Helplessness
Mar 21, 2018
Unlearn Helplessness
Mar 21, 2018
Mar 21, 2018
In Medicine, How Can We Honor Introverts?
Mar 13, 2018
In Medicine, How Can We Honor Introverts?
Mar 13, 2018
Mar 13, 2018
Feb 10, 2018
Stick To That Goal
Feb 10, 2018
Feb 10, 2018
Lessons In The Madness
Feb 2, 2018
Lessons In The Madness
Feb 2, 2018
Feb 2, 2018
You're Unbalanced. That's Okay.
Jan 28, 2018
You're Unbalanced. That's Okay.
Jan 28, 2018
Jan 28, 2018
Lose Your Identity On Purpose
Jan 26, 2018
Lose Your Identity On Purpose
Jan 26, 2018
Jan 26, 2018
Jan 17, 2018
The Things That Inspire Me
Jan 17, 2018
Jan 17, 2018
Success Is A Jungle Gym, Not A Ladder
Jan 15, 2018
Success Is A Jungle Gym, Not A Ladder
Jan 15, 2018
Jan 15, 2018
The Concept of "Good Enough" in Medicine
Jan 8, 2018
The Concept of "Good Enough" in Medicine
Jan 8, 2018
Jan 8, 2018
“You’re Too Small To Be A Surgeon” and Other Things Women in Medicine Hear
Jan 3, 2018
“You’re Too Small To Be A Surgeon” and Other Things Women in Medicine Hear
Jan 3, 2018
Jan 3, 2018
Why Giving Up Control Is The Best Thing You Can Do
Dec 30, 2017
Why Giving Up Control Is The Best Thing You Can Do
Dec 30, 2017
Dec 30, 2017
Give Yourself The Gift of Solitude
Dec 28, 2017
Give Yourself The Gift of Solitude
Dec 28, 2017
Dec 28, 2017
A Weird Reason I'm Thankful For Medical School
Dec 24, 2017
A Weird Reason I'm Thankful For Medical School
Dec 24, 2017
Dec 24, 2017
Dec 21, 2017
How Medical School Is Like Playing Defense
Dec 21, 2017
Dec 21, 2017
How To Find The Mentors You Want 
Dec 17, 2017
How To Find The Mentors You Want 
Dec 17, 2017
Dec 17, 2017
It Is Okay To Not Feel Okay
Dec 15, 2017
It Is Okay To Not Feel Okay
Dec 15, 2017
Dec 15, 2017
The Lesson Death Teaches Us
Dec 11, 2017
The Lesson Death Teaches Us
Dec 11, 2017
Dec 11, 2017
The Ones Who Walk Away
Dec 7, 2017
The Ones Who Walk Away
Dec 7, 2017
Dec 7, 2017
Find Your People.
Nov 29, 2017
Find Your People.
Nov 29, 2017
Nov 29, 2017
Why Do Medical Students and Physicians Have Mental Health Issues?
Nov 26, 2017
Why Do Medical Students and Physicians Have Mental Health Issues?
Nov 26, 2017
Nov 26, 2017
The Type of Physician I Am Training To Be
Nov 22, 2017
The Type of Physician I Am Training To Be
Nov 22, 2017
Nov 22, 2017
A Lesson in a Parking Lot
Nov 18, 2017
A Lesson in a Parking Lot
Nov 18, 2017
Nov 18, 2017
Tags medicine, healthcare, meded, medical school, physicians, philosophy, patient, nurse, pa, np, rn, do, md
← “You’re Too Small To Be A Surgeon” and Other Things Women in Medicine HearGive Yourself The Gift of Solitude →

Subscribe

Get the latest blogs and updates delivered to your e-mail!

We respect your privacy.

Thank you!
Facebook